When planning a backyard improvement in Buffalo, one of the most critical decisions is selecting the correct sort of inground pool. While there are several pool varieties to consider, concrete and fiberglass pools are two of the more reliable and popular options. Each solution has advantages and disadvantages, and your choice will have a long-term impact on the pool’s design, maintenance, and lifespan.
If you’re thinking about fiberglass pool installation Buffalo NY, or a concrete pool builder Buffalo NY, this guide will walk you through all you need to know. We’ll compare both types based on crucial aspects like durability, maintenance, install time, available pool shapes, and pool liner alternatives.
Comparison of Fiberglass Pools vs. Concrete Pools
What is a fiberglass pool?
A fiberglass pool is pre-manufactured at a factory as a single solid piece. It is brought straight to your property and installed in the prepared ground. These pools come in a variety of sizes and forms, with a sleek, low-maintenance finish. Because they arrive ready to use, installation is usually faster than with other kinds of pools, making them an excellent choice for homeowners looking for something quick and easy.
What is a concrete pool?
Concrete pools, also known as shotcrete or gunite pools, are created on-site from the ground up. This technology allows homeowners to manage every aspect of the pool’s shape, features, and depth. Although they take more time to build, concrete pools are the top pick for people who want something custom that fits their landscape or unique design ideas.
If you’re deciding between pool types, check out this comparison of fiberglass vs. concrete pools to see which is best for your backyard.
Installation Time: How Long Will It Take?
Fiberglass pools: Quick and efficient.
One of the most advantageous aspects of fiberglass pool installation in Buffalo NY, is how quickly the job can be accomplished. After you’ve decided on a design and obtained the necessary licenses, the process may be completed quickly, often in two or three weeks. Because the pool shell is built off-site, the majority of the effort consists of digging the hole and installing the shell.
This is especially useful in Buffalo, where the outdoor building season is quite brief. In just a few weeks, you may be swimming instead of waiting for construction to finish.
Concrete Pools: A Longer Process.
Concrete pools require more time and labor. Since everything is built on location, from digging to framing, spraying the concrete, and curing it can take anywhere from 8 to 12 weeks or longer. Weather can cause delays, which is something to keep in mind in Buffalo’s unpredictable climate.
Design Flexibility and Pool Shapes
Concrete pools are fully customizable.
Concrete is the preferred material for individuals looking to create a specific design. You may completely customize the layout, including unique features such as waterfalls and sun shelves, and construct almost any form you wish. A concrete pool builder in Buffalo, NY, can create a natural lagoon look or a sophisticated geometric plan.
Fiberglass Pools, Stylish but Limited Shapes.
Fiberglass pools provide a wide range of modern, appealing pool shapes, but they are limited to what manufacturers already produce. That implies that if your ideal design is very personalized or oddly shaped, fiberglass may be unable to produce exactly what you desire.
Winner for Pool Shapes: Concrete wins out for complete design freedom.
Upkeep and Maintenance
Fiberglass pools: Minimal effort required.
One major reason people prefer fiberglass pool construction in Buffalo, NY, is the ease of maintenance. The non-porous surface resists algae and requires fewer chemicals. You won’t have to worry about changing liners or resurfacing the pool anytime soon.
As a result, fiberglass is an excellent choice for homeowners who wish to spend more time in their pool while cleaning it less frequently.
Concrete pools require more work.
Concrete pools require more frequent upkeep. Because of their rough, porous nature, algae and grime are more likely to adhere. This implies that more scrubbing and chemicals are required to keep everything clean. Also, concrete pools require resurfacing every 7 to 15 years, which adds to the long-term costs.
Therefore, Fiberglass is clearly easier and cheaper to maintain over time.
Durability and Longevity
Concrete Pools: Extremely Durable
Concrete pools have a reputation for lasting a long time, sometimes even 50 years or more if they’re well cared for. They can handle tough conditions and aren’t easily damaged by sharp objects or shifting soil.
Fiberglass pools: Strong, but not unbreakable.
Fiberglass pools are also extremely long-lasting and have advanced significantly in recent years. However, in regions like Buffalo, where freeze-thaw cycles are typical, ground movement can put stress on the fiberglass shell. Fortunately, improved materials and building processes have made them more adaptable and durable than previously.
So, it can be considered a tie, because each has advantages based on how well they’re maintained and the environment.
The Cost: Upfront and long-term expenses.
Fiberglass: Cost-effective Over Time
Fiberglass pools may be slightly more expensive than vinyl pools initially, but they are frequently less expensive than concrete in the long run. This is because the installation process is faster and involves less work. Furthermore, fiberglass pools offer reduced long-term expenditures because they do not require resurfacing or extensive chemical use.
Concrete: Higher Investment, Higher Maintenance.
Concrete pools are initially more expensive. Custom work and lengthier build times increase the cost. Over time, the necessity for resurfacing and more chemicals can add to your pool’s total cost.
In the long run, fiberglass is usually more cost-effective than other materials.
For an updated 2025 comparison of durability, cost, and maintenance, read our guide on fiberglass vs. concrete pools.
Comfort and Surface Feel
Fiberglass Pools
Fiberglass pools feature a smooth gel coat that feels soft on the skin and feet. This makes them a popular option for families with kids or people who spend a lot of time in the water.
Concrete Pools
Concrete has a rougher feel unless you choose a special finish, like tile or pebble, which can improve comfort but will raise the cost. In some cases, the rough surface can cause scrapes or irritation.
So, Fiberglass takes the lead for a softer swim experience.
Pool Liner Alternatives
If you would like to avoid the inconvenience of replacing vinyl liners, you need to understand how each choice compares.
Fiberglass pools do not use liners. The pool shell is a single solid unit with a sealed surface, so there is no chance of fading, tearing, or leaking liners.
Concrete pools do not require liners, but their surface wears down and needs to be resurfaced from time to time.
So, if avoiding liner problems is vital to you, both options work, but fiberglass often lasts longer and requires fewer surface repairs.
What Are the Most Important Factors in Your Decision?
Choose a Fiberglass Pool for:
- Quick installation.
- Low maintenance is a high priority.
- Comfort and smooth surfaces are crucial.
- You want to save money over time.
Consider a concrete pool if you want:
- A customized design.
- You don’t mind the extended installation time.
- You are okay with more hands-on upkeep.
- Durability and design flexibility are essential.
Trying to decide between fiberglass and concrete? We break down the pros and cons of fiberglass vs. concrete pools to help you choose the best option for your home.
Conclusion
Whether you choose fiberglass pool installation Buffalo NY, or a concrete pool builder Buffalo NY, the perfect inground pool is determined by your goals, budget, and design choices.
Both pool types have much to offer. With the assistance of knowledgeable professionals in Buffalo, NY, pool building, you can make an informed decision that matches your lifestyle and is compatible with Buffalo’s seasonal environment. Consider what is most important, whether it’s maintenance, personalization, pool forms, or pool liner options, and you’ll end up with a backyard pool you’ll enjoy for years.
FAQ
If you are searching for something low-maintenance, fiberglass pools are the best option. The smooth, non-porous surface inhibits algae growth and reduces the number of chemicals required as compared to concrete pools.
Fiberglass pools come in a variety of beautiful, pre-molded shapes, but they do not provide the same amount of customization as concrete pools.
With appropriate installation and winterization by a qualified Buffalo, NY, pool construction expert, both fiberglass and concrete pools can withstand Buffalo's frigid winters.
Want to make your backyard dream a reality? Contact KD Pool Builders today for experienced advice and skilled fiberglass pool installation in Buffalo, NY, or custom concrete pools at 716-300-2773. Our experts will guide you through each stage to ensure that your new pool exactly suits your style, budget, and timeline.
